Mets 2009 First-Year Player Draft picks
| 72 | Steven Matz | LHP | 6'02" | 192 | 5/29/1991 |
| 103 | Robert Shields | SS | 6'01" | 195 | 12/7/1987 |
| 134 | Darrell Ceciliani | CF | 6'01" | 185 | 6/22/1990 |
| 164 | Damien Magnifico | RHP | 6'01" | 180 | 5/24/1991 |
| 194 | David Buchanan | RHP | 6'03" | 190 | 5/11/1989 |
| 224 | Darin Gorski | LHP | 6'04" | 210 | 10/6/1987 |
| 254 | John Freeman | C | 6'00" | 200 | 8/24/1987 |
| 284 | Jeffrey Glenn | C | 6'03" | 185 | 9/22/1991 |
| 314 | Nick Santomauro | RF | 6'02" | 205 | 6/13/1988 |
| 344 | Samuel Honeck | 1B | 6'02" | 215 | 6/19/1987 |
| 374 | James Ewing | 2B | 6'00" | 195 | 10/27/1986 |
| 404 | Zachary Dotson | LHP | 6'01" | 180 | 10/30/1990 |
| 434 | Ronald Harris | CF | 6'02" | 205 | 2/19/1987 |
| 464 | Casey Schmidt | RHP | 6'03" | 205 | 10/12/1987 |
| 494 | Jeffrey Greene | CF | 5'11" | 180 | 4/22/1990 |
| 524 | Alexander Gregory | OF | 6'02" | 210 | 11/7/1986 |
| 554 | Cody Holliday | OF | 6'03" | 210 | 9/30/1987 |
| 584 | Nelfi Zapata | C | 6'00" | | 12/13/1990 |
| 614 | Joseph August | OF | 6'01" | 205 | 9/23/1986 |
| 644 | Joseph Bonfe | 3B | 6'04" | 220 | 12/28/1987 |
| 674 | Zachary Von Tersch | RHP | 6'04" | 195 | 4/22/1988 |
| 704 | John Church | RHP | 6'03" | 235 | 11/4/1986 |
| 734 | Michael Johnson | RHP | 5'10" | 180 | 9/14/1987 |
| 764 | Josh Dunn | 3B | 6'03" | 215 | 12/9/1990 |
| 794 | John Semel | OF | 6'00" | 182 | 3/31/1988 |
| 824 | Kurt Steinhauer | OF | 6'01" | 205 | 3/29/1986 |
| 854 | Brian Needham | RHP | 6'07" | 180 | 9/21/1986 |
| 884 | ZeErika Hall | OF | 5'11" | 185 | 6/29/1988 |
| 914 | Jordan Harrison | LHP | 6'01" | 180 | 4/9/1991 |
